Skip to Main Content

Architects

Basic Biographic Details

Ebenezer James MacRae
Architect
Exact Date
Exact Date
15/01/1951
Kilcalmonell, Argyll

Ebenezer James MacRae was born on 18 January 1881, ‘a son of the manse’ in Clachan, Kilcalmonell, Argyll. His father was Alexander MacRae, a minister of the Free Church of Scotland and his mother was Annie Macrae, herself the daughter of another Free Kirk Minister. Somewhat surprisingly he was articled to the Roman Catholic Archibald Macpherson in 1899 and remained with him as draughtsman and assistant until December 1907. Macpherson, of whom he wrote in an affectionate memoir, was to remain a close friend for as long as he lived. During his time with Macpherson he studied at the School of Applied Art under Frank Worthington Simon from 1899 to 1904, concurrently attending Edinburgh University (1901-02) under Professor Gerald Baldwin Brown, and Heriot-Watt College (1901-07); from 1904 he attended the classes at the newly merged Edinburgh College of Art, including those in antique figure drawing, completing the course in 1906. During these early years he undertook sketching and measuring tours of York (1902 and 1904), Melrose (1904), Belgium (1905), Cambridge and Lincoln (1907) and Northamptonshire, Cambridge and Oxford (1907).

At the beginning of 1908 he moved to the office of John Kinross to spend six months assisting on his competition entry for the restoration of Kirkwall Cathedral, thereafter accepting a salaried post in the City Architect's Department under James Anderson Williamson. The following year, in collaboration with William Davidson who had been a fellow draughtsman in Macpherson's office, he exhibited designs for the furnishing and restoration of two Norfolk churches at the Royal Scottish Academy. Further collaborative designs were exhibited in 1911 and 1919, but the association between Davidson and MacRae appears to have been a loose one, as there is no evidence of a formal partnership having existed. He made additional tours of Paris in 1909, York in 1911, Norfolk in 1912 and Normandy in 1913. Surviving notes from this time show MacRae's interest in ecclesiastical architecture.

MacRae was admitted LRIBA in the mass intake of 20 July 1911, proposed by James Bow Dunn and the Edinburgh Architectural Association; but with characteristic determination he passed the qualifying exam in 1914 and was admitted ARIBA late that year, his proposers this time being Macpherson, John Watson, one of the teachers at the School of Applied Art and at Edinburgh College of Art and Alexander Lorne Campbell.

In the First World War MacRae served with the Royal Engineers. He returned to the City Architect's Office in 1918, becoming Depute City Architect at some time prior to 1925 and succeeding Williamson as City Architect in July of the latter year. He was admitted FRIBA in 1934, proposed by Thomas Forbes Maclennan. Later that year he and Wilson were members of the Department of Health fact-finding team led by the Permanent Secretary John Highton which toured the continental housing estates in Rotterdam, Amsterdam, Berlin, Frankfurt, Prague, Vienna and Paris. He compiled much of the analysis that appeared in the subsequent report which had a profound influence on local authority housing in the late 1930s.

MacRae was sympathetic to conservation, and would have perhaps reconditioned more buildings for housing if the subsidies available under the 1919 Act had continued. He renovated a number of Old Town buildings, like the Candlemakers Hall for club rooms, and where that was not practicable he rebuilt or retained several facades in something similar to their original form.  However, there were also several historic buildings demolished in his tenure, including tenements on the Canongate and Grassmarket, and those either side of the City Chambers removed for its extension.  The seventeenth century frontage of the Tailor's Hall complex on the Cowgate was a major loss.   Towards the end of his tenure he undertook a survey of the Old Town,  assisted by a newly qualified planner, William Dey, later of Gordon & Dey.  In 1945 and 1947 he produced policy reports on 'The Royal Mile', and followed this up with a another document, 'The Heritage of Greater Edinburgh', which listed all the traditional buildings in the city which were worthy of retention, very much in parallel with the Marquess of Bute's lists for the country as a whole.  It is useful to look at an earlier study of the Royal Mile undertaken around 40 years earlier by Bruce Home for the Old Edinburgh Club in 1908.   A large collection of related papers is preserved in Edinburgh Central Library. His interest also extended to historic statuary, and he published an essay on the 'Lead Equestrian Statue of Charles II' in the Book of the Old Edinburgh Club.  

MacRae retired in July 1946, but continued to be influential in a variety of fields, remaining a member of the RIAS Council until 1950. He had a particular interest in the Edinburgh Cripple and Invalid Children's Aid Society to which he gave generously of his time and money and was ornithologist, photographer and watercolourist, exhibiting at the RSA from 1915 until 1940. Several of the subjects record his travels in France c.1914 and Germany c.1930. John Ross McKay wrote of him that 'as an official he was easy of approach. His innate courtesy and charm of manner made it a pleasure to visit him...he was always ready to assist and never adopted the reserve of the official'.

He died on 15 January 1951 at the Deaconess hospital, Edinburgh, his home address then being Taprobane, Ratho., a house built for him.   His wiife, Dorothy Craigie, survived him.



'Biography authored by the Dictionary of Scottish Architects Compilation Team.'

Addresses

The following private or business addresses are associated with this person:

Private Addresses

Private Addresses2 classic

AddressClassDate From CharDate From TypeDate To CharDate To TypeNotes
17 Braid Terrace Crescent Edinburgh ScotlandPrivate
64 Frederick Street Edinburgh ScotlandPrivate
Taprobane Ratho Midlothian ScotlandPrivate1951Year
9 Albert Terrace Edinburgh ScotlandPrivate

Business Addresses

Business Addresses2 classic

AddressClassDate From Date From TypeDate ToDate To TypeNotes
Royal Exchange Edinburgh ScotlandBusiness1930 or 1931After 1939|1940

Employment and Training

The following individuals or organisations employed or trained this person (click on an item to view details):

Employers2 classic

NameName LinkDate FromDate ToPositionNotes
Archibald Macpherson2006971899/06/01In year 1903Apprentice
John Kinross2009651908/011908/06Assistant
James Anderson Williamson2006941908/06c. 1914Assistantin Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Edinburgh City Architect's Department (Edinburgh Corporation)2019641908/06c. 1914Assistantunder James Anderson Williamson, City Architect
Edinburgh City Architect's Department (Edinburgh Corporation)2019641925/071946/07Chief ArchitectCity Architect
Archibald Macpherson200697In year 19031907/12Assistant
Edinburgh City Architect's Department (Edinburgh Corporation)201964In year 19181925/07ArchitectDepute City Architect

Employees or Pupils

The following individuals were employed or trained by this person (click on an item to view details):

Employees or Pupils2 classic

NameName LinkDate FromDate ToPositionNotes
David V Findlay409125In year 1898In year 1937ClerkChief Clerk in Edinburgh City Architects Department
John Mailler Scott204664In year 1922In year 1942AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Thomas William Leslie Dorrance206868In year 1924In year 1929Apprenticein Edinburgh City Architects Department
David Gordon Bannerman204317In year 1924AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
John Wright Ford205647In year 1925After 1930AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Andrew Arnot McCulloch100406In year 1925In year 1945Assistant ArchitectIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Thomas Smith409112In year 1925In year 1946Assistant ArchitectIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Ion Victor Godfrey Hamilton Warner207525In year 19261928/05AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Robert Jonas Gildard200946In year 19261930sAssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
James Macgregor Harvey205632In year 1927In year 1946AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
James Moffatt Aitken206450In year 1928In year 1937AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architect's Department
Andrew Rollo203018In year 1928In year 1946AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architects Department
Thomas William Leslie Dorrance206868In year 1929After 1947Assistantin Edinburgh City Architect\'s Office; excluding war years
George Clark Robb205264In year 1929In year 1936AssistantIn Edinburgh City Architects Department
Robert Smail409121In year 1929In year 1946Clerk of WorksIn Edinburgh City Architects Department

RIBA Proposers

The following individuals proposed this person for RIBA membership (click on an item to view details):

RIBA PROPOSERS2 classic

ProposerProposer LinkDate ProposedNotes
James Bow Dunn2001741911/07/20for Licentiateship - as president of Edinburgh Architectural Association
Alexander Lorne Campbell200379Late 1914sfor Associateship
John Watson202272Late 1914sfor Associateship
Archibald Macpherson200697Late 1914sfor Associateship
James Alexander Arnott1000441934/03/05for Fellowship
Thomas Forbes Maclennan1004041934/03/05for Fellowship
John Wilson2024011934/03/05for Fellowship

RIBA Proposals

This person proposed the following individuals for RIBA membership (click on an item to view details):

RIBA PROPOSALS2 classic

PersonDate ProposedNotes
Patrick McGowan Thompson1936/02/10for Associateship
Adam Bryce Kerr1936/03/09for Associateship
Ernest John Weir1936/03/09for Associateship
James Moffatt Aitken1937/03/08for Associateship
Eric Hutton Crosbee1938/01/10for Associateship
Peter Rice Whiston1938/01/10for Associateship
Annie Nicol Turnbull (Mrs Hubbard)1938/12/05for Associateship
Elizabeth Fergus Comrie (Miss)1939/02/06for Associateship
Alfred Hugh Mottram1939/03/06for Fellowship
George Clark Robb1940/04/16for Associateship
Robert Somerville Ellis1946/02/12for Licentiateship
James Macgregor Harvey1946/05/07for Licentiateship
David Ebenezer Lang1946/07/09For Associateship
Thomas William Leslie Dorrance1947/03/11for Licentiateship
(Sir) William Hardie Kininmonth1948/04/06for Fellowship

Buildings and Designs

This person was involved with the following buildings or structures from the date specified (click on an item to view details):

Buildings and Designs2 classic

Building NameDate StartedTown, District or VillageIslandCity or CountyCountryNotes
Our Lady of Loretto and St Michael RC Church, presbytery and hallIn year 1903MusselburghMidlothianScotlandAs assistant to Archibald Macpherson
Kirkwall CathedralIn year 1907KirkwallMainlandOrkneyScotlandCompetition tender for restoration - as assistant to John Kinross
Church of St HelenIn year 1909RanworthNorfolkEnglandDesigns for restoration - in collaboration with William Davidson
Gorgie Market, corn market, Corporation Slaughterhouse and police stationIn year 1909GorgieEdinburghScotlandAs assistant to James Anderson Williamson in City Architect's Office
Church of St Agnes, rood screenIn year 1909CawstonNorfolkEnglandDesign exhibited - in collaboration with William Davidson
Kilcalmonell Churchyard, War Memorial GatewayIn year 1921ArgyllScotland
Gorgie Market, corn market, Corporation Slaughterhouse and police stationIn year 1926GorgieEdinburghScotlandAlterations and Extension
Tram ShelterIn year 1926LeithEdinburghScotlandCity Architect
Prestonfield Housing Scheme - Council housingIn year 1927PrestonfieldEdinburghScotlandAs City Architect
Portobello Power StationIn year 1927PortobelloEdinburghScotlandMacRae design built, absorbing first section by Williamson. (In 1931 workshops and stores added)
St Margaret's ParkIn year 1927CorstorphineEdinburghScotlandLaid out park
Lauriston Castle, Stable CourtIn year 1927EdinburghScotland
Niddrie Mains housing - Council housingIn year 1928Niddrie MainsEdinburghScotland
74-84 GrassmarketIn year 1929Old TownEdinburghScotlandRestoration
Niddrie Housing EstateIn year 1929NiddrieEdinburghScotlandAs City Architect

References

Bibliographic References

The following books contain references to this person:

Bib ref classic

AuthorTitleDatePublisherPartNotes
RCAHMSHomebuilders: Mactaggart & Mickel and the Scottish housebuilding industry1999RCAHMSp 73, 75, 78, 82
Johnson, Jim and Rosenburg, LouRenewing Old Edinburgh: the Enduring Legacy of Patrick Geddes2010Glendaruel: Argyll Publishingp 151-157
RIBAThe RIBA Kalendar 1950-19511950London: Royal Institute of British Architects

Periodical References

The following periodicals contain references to this person:

Period ref classic

Periodical NamePublisherDate CircEditionNotes
Building Industries1951/02*Obituary
RIAS Quarterly1951/0584p56 Obituary
RIBA Journal1951/07*Obituary p370

Archive References

The following archives hold material relating to this person:

Arc ref classic

Archive NameSourceSource Cat NoBuilding IdItem NameNotes
RIBA Nomination PapersRIBA Archive, Victoria & Albert Museum100005L v19 no1443; A v22 no2543 (microfilm reel 22); F no3192 (box 18)
Information sent to DictionaryCourtesy of Christopher Gordon201200Sent September 2011
Death RegisterH M Register House100027